Search For Xo Elliott Smith @ Amazon.com
| Most helpful customer reviews 41 of 42 people found the following review helpful. There are two things that make this musician stand out in a crowd. First comes his incredible music. His harmonic textures and rhythmic off-beating constantly combine to create a much needed breath of fresh air in this bubblegum pop world. I didn’t realize how tired I was of the same old songs (and the same boring song form, ABA) until I listened to Elliot, and found his songs so beautiful in their difference. Second, his lyrics are extremely beautiful and very well crafted. This is not easy pop with lyrics that don’t mean anything important (or are already familiar because they say the exact same thing as every other pop band). Elliot tackles hard subjects such as depression and lonliness, and yet can balance it out with a song about personal change from something ugly into something beautiful (“independence day”).
So it comes to this: though it’s not quite polished, and can sometimes be a bit inscrutable, Elliot Smith’s music is profound nonetheless. XO is, in my opinion, one of the best examples of this and well worth anything you pay for it. 20 of 20 people found the following review helpful. “XO” clearly stands out from Smith’s previous work, simply based on how much production went into the album; no one could ever accuse “Roman Candle,” “Elliott Smith,” or “Either/or” of being over-produced. But I also think it would be a mistake to call “XO” overproduced. The rawness and urgency of Smith’s music are not glossed over, which is generally what is meant when an album is accused of being overproduced. Instead, Smith’s increased resources allow him to bring layers to his music that highlight–rather than detract from–the heart of his songs. Songs such as “Waltz #1″ and “Oh Well, Okay” demonstrate this point perfectly. These songs have all the lyrical and musical integrity and richness of Smith’s earlier work, yet he simply could not have produced them earlier, particularly in the case of “Waltz #1.” In spirit, however, these two songs–as well as the majority of the album–are a perfect continuation of Smith’s work. That they are “fuller” songs, at least musically, allows Smith’s talent to be more open and upfront, yet they still retain a certain quietness and subtlety. Several songs stand out as noticeably different from Smith’s earlier work, however. “Amity” sounds more like a song Smith would have written for Heatmiser than for a solo album; it is the one sour note on the album. I also find “Baby Britain” to be a new “type” of Smith song, though in this case the development is good. And the last song on the album, “I Didn’t Understand,” is a beautiful breathy a capella piece which very skillfully sums up the album’s themes and brings it to a close. “XO” had the chance of falling flat, precisely because of Smith’s expanded resources; there was a chance that he would not be able to transition from his minimalistic sound to a fuller one. However, as “XO’s” rich lushness demonstrates, Smith fulfilled the challenge well, and he produced a record that is true to the soul of his music. 36 of 42 people found the following review helpful. To me, this record feels like R.E.M.’s “Monster” or Archer Prewitt’s “White Sky,” a transition record setting the scene for something greater. There’re a lot of great songs on here, and they’re full of all of Smith’s trademarks; even the simplest phrases (“She looks so composed/So she is, I suppose”) are cleverly delivered and beautiful in their simplicity. But there’re also a lot of over-production which relies too much on the arrangement and not enough on the quiet passion or feeling which makes Elliott Smith the man. People here are saying that Elliott Smith is like the new Nick Drake, but Drake would never have produced a song like “Baby Britain,” which is campy and unconvincing, even as though it’s fun and has a neat-o harpsichord accent in the bridge. He hits the mark on songs like “Tomorrow, Tomorrow” or “Pitseleh,” and I really like “Independence Day,” but songs like “Amity” leave you feeling like you’ve just heard a B-side or an experiment, not a finished track. They’re more produced than his other songs, but there’s something lacking in the delivery or the songwriting. When Smith’s not as his very, very best, he gets smothered under all his production. Sometimes it’s lovely, as on “Bled White,” but sometimes it’s unnecessary, as on “Amity.”
All the greatness-that-could-have-been on XO is realized on Figure 8, a real five-star record. I say, buy Figure 8 or one of Smith’s earlier records before you buy XO. I listen to this CD all the time, but I listen to the others more, and I care about them more, too. I’d lend XO to a friend, I’d keep the others to myself. Xo Elliott Smith Picture Xo Elliott Smith Image Xo Elliott Smith Pic Xo Elliott Smith Picture |
Deserves every star
A great record – but not as great as some other Elliott.
